High End 2011 - Munich, Germany
- Details
- Written by Doug Schneider Doug Schneider
- Parent Category: High End 2011 High End 2011
- Created: 21 May 2011 21 May 2011
Hegel's Take on Asynchronous USB and "Super Exciting" Digital Connectors
Hegel's Bent Holter has some opinions about asynchronous USB connections that are sure to throw audiophiles into a tizzy, stir up some controversy, and cause some to say that it's flat-out heresy. Bent is the chief designer at Hegel, a Norwegian company with a 30-year track record. Bent believes that while an asynchronous USB connection can be a good way to transfer music data from a computer to a DAC, it's not the only way and it might not be the best way -- a claim that runs contrary to the thoughts of many who feel that asynchronous USB connections represent the holy grail of low-jitter data transfer.
To further explain his position, Bent invited us to sit down with him at High End so he could draw diagrams to illustrate how data travels inside a computer to outside it and into the DAC. He concedes that a properly implemented asynchronous USB connection can be a great, low-jitter transfer mechanism. With asynchronous USB transfer, it's the DAC's clock that controls the flow of data from the computer to it.
Bent feels, however, that as good or better jitter performance is possible by not worrying so much about the transfer of data from the computer to the DAC, and worrying more about dealing with jitter inside the DAC, which is Hegel's approach. Hegel puts into their DACs large buffers that store data when it arrives from the computer. Then, by using extremely precise, well-isolated clocks, they move that data from the buffer and through the DAC in perfect time until it's turned into an analog signal. He says that the measured jitter performance using this technique is as good or better than asynchronous USB.
Bent feels that additional improvements are possible by improving the DAC's connectors, which is where his talk about "super exciting" coaxial connectors comes in. If you doubt that coaxial connectors can be super exciting, which we did, just watch Bent's face as he talks about them and how fast his hand moves that pen across the paper when he explains it. I thought something was going to catch fire!
Bent cautions that typical RCA connectors are not 75 ohms, which is what they're supposed to be for S/PDIF connections. He says that BNC connectors come in proper 75-ohm types, but also 50-ohm types. His claim is that many manufacturers are using 50-ohm BNC connectors, which isn't a good thing either. In a nutshell, non-75-ohm connections and mismatched impedances cause reflections in the digital signal that, in turn, increases jitter.
Hegel prefers to use the more common RCA connectors on their DACs, and since those aren't 75 ohms, they add a circuit to the connector to ensure that it presents a perfect 75-ohm impedance. This circuit is implemented on the company's HD20 DAC. Bent says that the improvements are not only easily measurable but also quite audible.
With AudioQuest's talk about the importance of USB and FireWire cables and Hegel's thoughts on asynchronous USB and coaxial connectors, it's obvious that digital music playback isn't as straightforward as many people think.
Doug Schneider
Publisher and Founder, The SoundStage! Network
Most-Read Last 90 Days
- Hans's Main Stereo System: KEF, Hegel, Siltech
- From Microsub to Tactical Nuke: Living with Perlisten's D15s Subwoofer
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: TAD’s Compact Evolution One—Concentric Excellence
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: Soundfield Audio’s Obelisk T710—The Most Ambitious Loudspeaker System at the Show
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: High-End, Very High-End, and Extremely High-End Loudspeakers—Børresen Acoustics, MC Audiotech, and Acora Acoustics
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: A Study in Speaker Contrasts—Endow Audio Bravura 12 and Clarisys Audio Minuet
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: Orchard Audio, M101, Shunyata Research, MSB Technology, and Coastal Source
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: Four-Figure Gear in a Sea of Unobtanium—Soulnote, Diptyque Audio, Audia Flight, Unison Audio, and Moonriver Audio
- The Bristol Hi-Fi Show 2023, Part 2
- The Bristol Hi-Fi Show 2023, Part 1
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: Introduction Plus Focal and Naim Audio Product Coverage
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: Pro-Ject Audio Systems, Rotel, RME, and Falcon Acoustics Product Coverage
- Florida International Audio Expo 2023: Avantgarde Acoustic’s Duo GT—High-End Horns from the House of Stereo
- The Bristol Hi-Fi Show 2023, Part 3
- New Noise #8: Audio Oopsies